A Window To Perceptive Journalism

Capt plays to the gallery,
works the back-channels

S P Singh

Chandigarh 

"YOUR beleaguered Chief Minister is back," Amarinder Singh announced, almost gleefully, as he faced the Punjab media for the first time since his move to block the SYL canal caused a political earthquake in New Delhi. 

Mindful of the state-level heroism thrust upon him, and caught amidst the outrage elsewhere, he played martyr to the hilt. He dodged questions on what the Prime Minister had said to him, though he did not deny any harsh words. 

When a reporter hesitantly asked him about his meeting with Dr Manmohan Singh, the Chief Minister finished the question for him: "You mean did the Prime Minister give me a tongue-lashing? Well I can't discuss what happened between me and the PM. That is confidential." 

To him, the more serious issue was the degree of flak that Punjab's move had drawn. "People are not viewing us as the aggrieved party but as the villain," he said. 

But beyond the grandstanding, he did make two points: That the time for political solutions was long past and the matter would only be settled in courts, for which he had assembled a high-powered team. 

The Indian Express also understands that Amarinder has not exactly wasted the past couple of days in New Delhi. Apart from explaining their legal position, his team has been speaking to party leaders about one possible fallout of this controversy: The return of terrorism. 

At the press conference the Chief Minister could only say that 16 lakh people would lose their livelihood if the SYL canal went ahead and deprived some parts of Punjab of water. "Some problems can take Punjab to the bad old days," he added. 

But behind the scenes The Indian Express understands, Punjab has been elaborating on this point to the Centre. It has pointed out that the terrorist problem began almost immediately after the SYL project got the go-ahead in 1982. And to show that militancy still holds fascination for some, it has spoken of how Sarabjit Singh, the son of Indira Gandhi's assassin Beant, garnered more than one lakh votes in the recent elections despite being a complete novice. 

Punjab's politicians have been trying to argue that water is such an emotive issue in the state that it can easily bring back a threat that has been quelled.  

But in realpolitik, the argument may not work. Amarinder himself admitted at the press conference that negotiations were pointless as neither he nor Haryana would yield ground. "The situation has moved beyond that," he said. 

That left him with the legal option. "I am not defiant of the Supreme Court," he said. "But I am determined (to uphold Punjab’s interests)." 

Asked if he regretted his move, he shot back: "Do I look remorseful?" 

And if he was beleaguered, he did not look it either.■ 

July 16, 2004

Also See:

― Govt plans legislation to escape SYL
― Govt mulled tweaking 131-yr-old Act for SYL 
― CM to meet Sorabjee today 
― Punjab annuls all Ravi-Beas pacts...
― My days numbered, said CM 
― SYL: Centre’s eyes were wide shut
― How CM’s Team Legal found an enabling loophole 
― Experts say Punjab Act dilutes riparian concept 
― Capt finds solace in Narmada Tribunal’s report
― State suggested Presidential Reference
― ‘Presidential Reference is good news’
― Capt changes tune
― Amarinder demanded this in '87

Print this article

     
Home     Latest Column     SP Singh's Columns     Spice Of Politics     People     This Land Of Ours     Ballot Field     Across Radcliffe     Punjab's Religio-Politics

     
Cinema~Books~Life     Three Lines At A Time     Guest Column     Glossary     Archives     Grapevine    SP Singh     Contact     Search     Site Index     Site Map     Feedback

      © 2006       All rights reserved        Site design by Big Ideas